Brexit – a term that, in the past one year, has evoked countless debates, arguments, discussions, fears and hopes across the UK like no other. With the referendum on whether the UK should leave or stay in the European Union going to polls in less than a week from now, the debate has become more intense than ever before. However, most of these debates and discussions so far have been characterised by exaggeration, bias and distortion. Each side, while highlighting their pro aspects, have done their best to also highlight the cons of the other side. How does this affect the health service and those attached to it?
The recent defection by one of the most authoritative voices of the NHS, Dr. Sarah Wollaston from the Leave side to the Remain Side, has once again brought the impact on the NHS into the spotlight. Let us look at the arguments raised by the two sides with regard to Brexit.
Having pledged that they will redirect Britain’s annual spending on the EU amounting to £5.2 billion to the NHS, the leave campaigner’s claim that migration from the EU has been responsible for the increased pressure on the health service. They further add that with Turkey and three other countries ready to join the EU in a short time, the number of migrants will go up, adding to the pressure.
According to the remain campaigner’s, the likelihood of an economic shock for the UK, in the event that it leaves the EU, would translate to less funding for the health services. They also raise questions about the future of 130,000 non-British EU citizens working in the health services and social care sector; as their visa status would become uncertain in the event of the UK leaving the EU.
A closer look at the claims from both sides
In order to fully understand the implication of Brexit on the health services, it is important to take a close look at the claims from both the Leave and the Remain campaigns.
- The Leave campaigners' have pledged £5.2 billion annually or £100 million per week to the NHS. This has been scaled down from the £350 million per week that they were suggesting earlier as this was the amount that the UK paid to the EU on a weekly basis. Actually, after subtracting Britain’s rebate and the EU funding to the UK; Britain actually pays around £150 million every week. This is enough to cover the £100 million promised, or is it? According to the majority of independent economists, leaving the EU would lead to an economic shock for the UK that could leave the Government with a £20 billion to £40 billion in arrears by 2020, translating to a deficit of between £380 million to £770 million per week. If the post-Brexit Government does give the promised £100 million to the NHS, it would only be possible if they cut into expenditures incurred for other sectors.
- There is no doubt that an increase in population will create an increased demand on the health service of the nation. The point that the Leave campaign people are making about the increased pressure on the health services due to the migration into the UK by people from the EU does make sense. However, there is more to this situation than stated by them. The health system in the UK is publicly funded; i.e. it is paid for by the taxpayers. Out of all EU migrants in the UK who are within the working age, 78% are working, which stands to reason that most of them are paying taxes and thus contributing to the funding of the NHS. A large number of these migrants are young and thus have little requirements for NHS services. Add to that the 130,000 or more EU citizens who work in the healthcare sector and you get a far clearer picture on the migrant issue.
NHS and NHS staff viewpoint
According to the chief executive of NHS England, Simon Stevens, “It would be very dangerous if at precisely the moment the NHS is going to need extra funding actually the economy goes into a tailspin and that funding is not there.”
Although the Royal College of Nursing, the BMA and the main trade unions have not taken any official position on Brexit, the BMA has issued a document listing the pros and cons for the NHS, the profession and the nation’s health emanating from the EU membership. The Royal College of Midwives, the Royal College of Physicians and the doctor’s professional body have backed the Remain campaign.
What does it mean for our nurses?
How will the vote affect you – our nurses? As of now, most nurses have their qualifications recognised across Europe, as per the agreed EU minimum standards for education. Similarly, nurses from other European countries can work in the UK. Health and safety and employment protection so far have been negotiated at the EU level. What is not clear is how these will be handled once the UK leaves the EU.
We stand committed to finding the perfect placements for our nurses, along with helping our nurses build their careers through our training courses and counselling sessions.
We at The Flame Lily will keep you posted on the possible implications of the vote and are there to answer all your queries. We would also like to hear from you regarding your questions and comments on how you think the referendum will affect you.
The UK government is offering nearly 1 million of its NHS staff pay-raise up to 6.5% over a period o...
Healthcare agencies providing external staffing to the NHS are claiming the institution inflated the...
Are you from European Economic Area (EEA) and want to work in the UK? NHS (National Health Services)...